Long: Re: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning

Date: Sun, 11 Oct 2015 09:02:23 -0300 (ADT)
From: "rita.paul@ns.sympatico.ca" <rita.paul@ns.sympatico.ca>
To: naturens@chebucto.ns.ca
References: <904484737.68429.1444393880884.open-xchange@webmail.bellaliant.net> <BB70A87CFE8B8B4597E5A9D5EDDAB6FB548458F9@AS446.prov.gov.ns.ca>,<7A6A7E7CC2494F1BA399C870D5516E3B@D58WQPH1> <BB70A87CFE8B8B4597E5A9D5EDDAB6FB54845C0E@AS446.prov.gov.ns.ca>,<4E086126C64E4DCD8D8E5D04F65BB97B@D58WQPH1> <BB70A87CFE8B8B4597E5A9D5EDDAB6FB54845CB1@AS446.prov.gov.ns.ca>
Importance: Medium
Precedence: bulk
Return-Path: <naturens-mml-owner@chebucto.ns.ca>
Original-Recipient: rfc822;"| (cd /csuite/info/Environment/FNSN/MList; /csuite/lib/arch2html)"

next message in archive
no next message in thread
previous message in archive
previous message in thread
Index of Subjects

&gt; of artifi
<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Strict//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-strict.dtd"><html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"><head>
    <meta content="text/html; charset=UTF-8" http-equiv="Content-Type"/>
 
 </head><body style="">
 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">Very interesting Dave and Andrew.</span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">Up and out before the sun and not coming in til after dark<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">was very interesting at this time of year. even if harvesting potatoes was<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">hard work! <br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">One evening after the sun went down and we were finishing up one<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">member of the crew pointed out a bright light going across the sky.<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">More like the sun reflecting of metal rather than a light. It wasn&#39;t very high<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">higher than an airplane but not as high as satellites nowadays. From the newspapers</span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">of the day we deduced it was&#160;an early Russian satellite - an memorable sighting.</span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">Enjoy the day</span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   <span style="font-size: 12pt;">Paul&#160;&#160;<br/></span>
  </div> 
  <div>
   &#160;
  </div> 
  <div>
   &#160;
  </div> 
  <div>
   <br/>&#62; On October 10, 2015 at 8:21 PM &#34;Hebda, Andrew J&#34; &#60;Andrew.Hebda@novascotia.ca&#62; wrote:
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; Thanks David
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; That makes sense.
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; Now with a low tide (here at about 06:40 - Noel), that pretty well guarantees the cold dense air will win tonight. 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; A
   <br/>&#62; ________________________________________
   <br/>&#62; From: naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca [naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca] on behalf of David &#38; Alison Webster [dwebster@glinx.com]
   <br/>&#62; Sent: October-10-15 8:09 PM
   <br/>&#62; To: naturens@chebucto.ns.ca
   <br/>&#62; Subject: Re: Long: Re: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; Hi Andrew &#38; All,
   <br/>&#62; I didn&#39;t express my thoughts very clearly. As in &#34;This rise of a warmer
   <br/>&#62; air mass above high ground will lead to a compensating upward flow of cooler
   <br/>&#62; air from lower levels&#34;. And I left out a lot, such as expansion of the
   <br/>&#62; rising warmed air body and concurrent cooling which as I recall occupies
   <br/>&#62; about four chapters in an introductory Met. book and lets not go there.
   <br/>&#62; So I will take another run at it. The initial state of the model is
   <br/>&#62; sunlight hitting some area of high ground, which is located at the summit of
   <br/>&#62; a long east-facing slope, and this insolation leads to warming of the
   <br/>&#62; overlying air. This will result in an updraft accompanied by a downdraft
   <br/>&#62; around the perimeter of the warmed area and inflow of unheated air in under
   <br/>&#62; the rising air body which will then be warmed; a Stirling engine without
   <br/>&#62; pistons, cylinders or drive shaft. As the sun rises further the insolated
   <br/>&#62; area of the slope increases, increasingly lower elevations of the slope will
   <br/>&#62; be warmed and increasingly lower elevations of cooler air will become drawn
   <br/>&#62; into this circulation.
   <br/>&#62; But such updrafts and air pockets have no bearing on the pooling of
   <br/>&#62; coldest air into frost hollows. This is best visualized by considering the
   <br/>&#62; flow of air in a long straight east-facing ravine which heads in a large
   <br/>&#62; barren at high elevation. Shortly after sundown has reached this ravine the
   <br/>&#62; air will start to cool, become more dense and flow down the ravine to
   <br/>&#62; create, over a period of several hours, a river of cold air. If there are
   <br/>&#62; low areas of ground in undulating terrain beyond the mouth of this model
   <br/>&#62; ravine then one may expect the coolest air to pool in these &#39;frost pockets&#39;.
   <br/>&#62; The same applies, in a less dramatic way, to any saucer-like depression at
   <br/>&#62; the lower reaches of a slope, however gradual the slope is. Coldest air,
   <br/>&#62; being most dense, will find its way to the frost hollow, displace any warmer
   <br/>&#62; air from it and then stagnate.
   <br/>&#62; These updrafts and air pockets can be quite intense even at mid-day when
   <br/>&#62; flying in light aircraft between terrain that is readily warmed (e.g. dry
   <br/>&#62; cultivated soil) and areas which are less readily warmed (e.g. lakes,
   <br/>&#62; woodland and moist meadows). You rise rapidly over the warmer area and can
   <br/>&#62; drop so rapidly when entering the cool that, with seatbelt not fastened, the
   <br/>&#62; plane roof drops with a bang onto your head.
   <br/>&#62; Meanwhile we may have our first frost tonight in the yard and I trust it
   <br/>&#62; knows how to do it.
   <br/>&#62; And I hope the second and third paragraphs make more sense that the
   <br/>&#62; brief version did.
   <br/>&#62; Yt, DW
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; ----- Original Message -----
   <br/>&#62; From: &#34;Hebda, Andrew J&#34; &#60;Andrew.Hebda@novascotia.ca&#62;
   <br/>&#62; To: &#60;naturens@chebucto.ns.ca&#62;
   <br/>&#62; Sent: Saturday, October 10, 2015 3:05 PM
   <br/>&#62; Subject: RE: Long: Re: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; 
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Thanks David
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; So what would the mechanism for the wider-scale &#34;frost-hollow&#34; phenomenon
   <br/>&#62; &#62; be? If denser, colder air is then drawn upward to replace the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; warmer-less-dense air, would that be creating a density gradient with
   <br/>&#62; &#62; colder/most dense air remaining at low levels?
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Andrew.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; ________________________________________
   <br/>&#62; &#62; From: naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca [naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca] on
   <br/>&#62; &#62; behalf of David &#38; Alison Webster [dwebster@glinx.com]
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Sent: October-10-15 2:28 PM
   <br/>&#62; &#62; To: naturens@chebucto.ns.ca
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Subject: Long: Re: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Hi Paul, Andrew &#38; All, Oct 10, 2015
   <br/>&#62; &#62; That is an interesting question Paul. In common with most natural
   <br/>&#62; &#62; phenomena there are no doubt several forces at work and I will describe
   <br/>&#62; &#62; what
   <br/>&#62; &#62; I suspect to be the major possible mechanism from first principles.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; I don&#39;t buy the explanation you suggested Andrew. Sun on high ground
   <br/>&#62; &#62; does not draw heat upward causing cold air to be drawn down.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Sun on high ground will warm the local air causing it to expand,
   <br/>&#62; &#62; decrease the density of this air mass and it will rise by the same forces
   <br/>&#62; &#62; that cause a hot air balloon to rise. This rise of a warmer air mass above
   <br/>&#62; &#62; high ground will lead to a compensating upward flow of cooler air from
   <br/>&#62; &#62; lower
   <br/>&#62; &#62; levels.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; It will help, I think, to consider some of the effective ways of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; warding
   <br/>&#62; &#62; off a marginal frost because this sheds some insight on mechanisms.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; (A) Nothing is gained by working all night when frost is unlikely so
   <br/>&#62; &#62; the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; first step is deciding when to prepare for action. In the days before
   <br/>&#62; &#62; weather forecasts frost omens were the combination of calm air and absence
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of cloud cover when evening temperatures were marginal. Thus, in the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; absence of lateral air movement, local cooling can be rapid if out
   <br/>&#62; &#62; radiation
   <br/>&#62; &#62; is not compensated by in radiation (from clouds).
   <br/>&#62; &#62; (B) And one time-tested strategy for frost avoidance is putting frost
   <br/>&#62; &#62; sensitive crops on a slope. Even in otherwise calm air the very slow
   <br/>&#62; &#62; downward flow of air under cooling conditions offers some protection. That
   <br/>&#62; &#62; this works also with tree fruits where the sensitive tissue is well above
   <br/>&#62; &#62; ground level suggests that transpiration from plant organs (leaves or
   <br/>&#62; &#62; flowers) is also a cause of cooling; thus airflow displaces this sheath of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; cooled air adjacent to the transpiring plant organs [Stomata will be open
   <br/>&#62; &#62; at
   <br/>&#62; &#62; night and the latent heat of vaporization is about 590 calories per gram
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; water at 10o C; enough heat to melt 7 grams of ice at 0o C.] This effect
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; air flow also applies to D.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; (C) One ancient way to avoid frost is smudge pots; fires in portable
   <br/>&#62; &#62; containers smothered with anything which will generate smoke and moved as
   <br/>&#62; &#62; necessary so smoke will drift over the crop. The heat generated by these
   <br/>&#62; &#62; fires is insignificant so protection, if any, is provided by back
   <br/>&#62; &#62; radiation
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of heat from the smoke which will be able to absorb some out radiation. A
   <br/>&#62; &#62; modern variant of this uses aerosols generated by spraying liquid onto a
   <br/>&#62; &#62; vibrating surface(I think).
   <br/>&#62; &#62; (D) Because frost develops when objects with the potential to cool
   <br/>&#62; &#62; rapidly are not warmed somewhat by a compensating inflow of warmer air or
   <br/>&#62; &#62; incoming radiation, one very effective way to avoid frost is the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; generation
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of artificial wind; either by large fans on tall towers or by flying low
   <br/>&#62; &#62; over the crop with a small plane throughout the critical dawn hours.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; E) Probably the most efficient and convenient means of frost protection
   <br/>&#62; &#62; is sprinkler irrigation when frost seems imminent. This will lead to
   <br/>&#62; &#62; significant ice formation on leaves and blossoms but the crop is protected
   <br/>&#62; &#62; because temperature can not drop below 0o C.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; F) For small plants in gardens (e.g. newly planted tomato plants) a
   <br/>&#62; &#62; gallon glass jug with the bottom cut off (cotton twine wet with gasoline
   <br/>&#62; &#62; then lit and jug placed in a tray of water just after flame dies) is
   <br/>&#62; &#62; effective if placed over the plant due to a greenhouse effect; heat from
   <br/>&#62; &#62; the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; soil and plant is trapped within the jug, except for a slow loss due to
   <br/>&#62; &#62; conduction, and this demonstrates that out radiation is a significant
   <br/>&#62; &#62; cause
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of cooling.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; G) Again for small gardens, e.g. Tomato plants tied to poles or
   <br/>&#62; &#62; sprawling, an old sheet draped over them and left overnight will help to
   <br/>&#62; &#62; keep in soil/plant heat which would otherwise be lost to radiation.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Getting back to the original question (why is frost hazard maximal near
   <br/>&#62; &#62; dawn ?) probably one major factor is a large reduction in back radiation;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; an
   <br/>&#62; &#62; object cools when out radiation exceeds in radiation. The haze which
   <br/>&#62; &#62; develops when air becomes saturated with water vapor and condenses onto
   <br/>&#62; &#62; dust
   <br/>&#62; &#62; particles probably provides significant in radiation (my guess). i.e.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; haze,
   <br/>&#62; &#62; water droplets so small they are evident only in a beam of light, can be
   <br/>&#62; &#62; expected to intercept radiation from plants or soil and radiate a portion
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; this back towards the ground and in effect act as low-lying clouds. How
   <br/>&#62; &#62; high
   <br/>&#62; &#62; this haze blanket extends I don&#39;t know but presumaby as high as the zone
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; saturation and this haze blanket will quickly thin from the top down as
   <br/>&#62; &#62; these tiny accumulations of water on dust particles are warmed by the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; first
   <br/>&#62; &#62; rays of the sun. So this haze blanket may be thought of as an
   <br/>&#62; &#62; earth-fitting
   <br/>&#62; &#62; wedge shaped layer which retreats westward as the sun rises, the upper
   <br/>&#62; &#62; surface being a tangent to the horizon and aimed at the sun.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; NOTE: these dust particles, really spores, pollen grains, salt crystals,
   <br/>&#62; &#62; smoke particles, very fine sand, silt or clay, etc. will also lead to some
   <br/>&#62; &#62; back radiation but not as effectively as water droplets due to the heat
   <br/>&#62; &#62; capacity of water and the capacity of haze sized droplets. In the absence
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; particles to serve as a nucleus water can not readily condense from
   <br/>&#62; &#62; saturated air due to a relatively high heat of fusion (79.7 cal/gram at
   <br/>&#62; &#62; 15o
   <br/>&#62; &#62; C). If two water molecules got together to start a water droplet then the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; heat released would be roughly equivalent to the heat required to raise
   <br/>&#62; &#62; their temperature by ~80o C; a difficult way to stay cool. Ionizing
   <br/>&#62; &#62; radiation also aids condensation (Wilson chamber) but this is a side
   <br/>&#62; &#62; issue.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; It is possible perhaps that the high concentrations of CO2, especially
   <br/>&#62; &#62; within plant intercellular spaces and on the underside of leaves, helps to
   <br/>&#62; &#62; hold tissue heat in (micro-greenhouse effect) and at the first rays of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; light
   <br/>&#62; &#62; this buildup of CO2 will start to decrease as photosynthesis kicks in.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; The outer surfaces of leaves and fruits carry an electrostatic charge
   <br/>&#62; &#62; because in the application of pesticides as tiny droplets at low volume
   <br/>&#62; &#62; the
   <br/>&#62; &#62; particles are given an opposite charge so they will be attracted to leaf
   <br/>&#62; &#62; and
   <br/>&#62; &#62; fruit surfaces (to minimize drift). Drawing on memory, these spray
   <br/>&#62; &#62; particles
   <br/>&#62; &#62; were given a negative charge which implies a positive charge on plant
   <br/>&#62; &#62; surfaces. I don&#39;t know how this charge develops but wonder if it is
   <br/>&#62; &#62; dependent on or reversed by photosynthesis. And if a wind of charges from
   <br/>&#62; &#62; the sharp tips of plant hairs could cause cooling. Electrostatics is full
   <br/>&#62; &#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62; surprises.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Yt, Dave Webster, Kentville
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; ----- Original Message -----
   <br/>&#62; &#62; From: &#34;Hebda, Andrew J&#34; &#60;Andrew.Hebda@novascotia.ca&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; To: &#60;naturens@chebucto.ns.ca&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Sent: Friday, October 09, 2015 9:55 AM
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Subject: RE: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Hi Paul
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; I remember reading somewhere that the reason was that the sun would hit
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; the top of the hills first, drawing heat upwards (convection?), that
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; would
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; then draw the colder air down the slopes to the hollows.. can&#39;t remember
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; where I saw that, but it seems to make sense (from the point of physics
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; of
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; air mass movement)
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Andrew
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; S________________________________________
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; From: naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca [naturens-owner@chebucto.ns.ca] on
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; behalf of rita.paul@ns.sympatico.ca [rita.paul@ns.sympatico.ca]
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Sent: October-09-15 9:31 AM
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; To: naturens@chebucto.ns.ca
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Subject: [NatureNS] Frost in the morning
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Hi All
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; In the old days on the farm we would be out before the
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Sun in early October. Not so much anymore! Then we would notice
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; that the white frost would form just as the sun broke the horizon
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; on a morning like this.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; This morning that happened also. When I went out before sun up there
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; was no white frost anywhere but half an hour latter everything was white.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; I assume it was enough to kill tender plants but we need wait and see.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; There used to be an explanation for that but I forget - I was never sure
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; if
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; it was correct or not! Perhaps someone will remember.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Enjoy the beautiful day
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Paul
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; -----
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; No virus found in this message.
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; Version: 2015.0.6172 / Virus Database: 4435/10783 - Release Date:
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62; 10/08/15
   <br/>&#62; &#62;&#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; &#62; -----
   <br/>&#62; &#62; No virus found in this message.
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
   <br/>&#62; &#62; Version: 2015.0.6172 / Virus Database: 4435/10791 - Release Date: 10/10/15
   <br/>&#62; &#62;
   <br/>&#62; 
  </div>
 
</body></html>

next message in archive
no next message in thread
previous message in archive
previous message in thread
Index of Subjects